Woman Branded Control Freak by Family for Refusing to Let Brother's Fiancée Wear Bridal White Gown to Her Wedding: 'Stop being so uptight!'

Author image for Ely Bulnes
Ely Bulnes • Writer and Editor
Dec 28, 2024 12:00 PM EST

Welcome, tea-spillers of the internet. Every wedding has its own dress code. Some weddings are pretty lax on what guests are expected to wear, and others are way more specific. It is becoming more an more popular to have a wedding color scheme that not only refers to the decorations but also to the colors that guests are expected to wear while attending the event. While these are still considered to be pretty extreme dress codes, some general rules are as follows: don't expose too much of your body, don't show up in jeans or shorts, and do not wear the same color as the bride, which in the West, is typically white.

In our story today, our protagonist is shocked to find out that her brother's fiancée plans to wear white to her wedding as a guest. With all of the colors of the rainbow to choose from, our OP suggests that she picks another dress for the event but is quickly branded a 'control freak' for setting the simplest of boundaries. Get all the details by scrolling down.

Advertisement
  • 01
    My brother's fiancée, Emily, approached me at our family Christmas gathering and casually mentioned that she found the "perfect dress" for my wedding. She pulled up a picture on her phone, and it was a full-on white gown. Not off- white or cream – straight up bridal white." -
    via Tetiana Ruvinska
  • 02
    r/AITAH u/Legion Breaker22 • 9h AITA for refusing to let my brother's fiancée wear white to my wedding?
    via u/LegionBreaker22
  • 03
    So, I (27F) am getting married in March to my fiancé (28M). We're keeping the wedding fairly traditional, and I've been looking forward to this day for years.
    via u/LegionBreaker22
  • 04
    Here's where the problem comes in: my brother's fiancée, Emily (25F), approached me at our family Christmas gathering and casually mentioned that she found the "perfect dress" for my wedding. She pulled up a picture on her phone, and it was a full- on white gown. Not off-white or cream-straight-up bridal white.
    via u/LegionBreaker22

    What's crazy is OP would've been open to ivory or cream white, but home girl still went for the bridal color. 

  • 05
    I was a little taken aback and said, "Oh, Emily, I don't think that'll work. Brides usually wear white, and it might confuse people." She kind of laughed it off and said, "It's fine, I'm not trying to upstage you or anything. I just love how I look in white." I told her I'd prefer if she found something else, but she brushed me off and said, "It's your day, no one's going to mistake me for the bride."
    via u/LegionBreaker22

    Girl, you have every color in the rainbow to choose from… 

  • 06
    I brought this up with my brother, and he got defensive, saying I'm "making a big deal out of nothing" and that Emily is "just being herself." He also accused me of being insecure if I think people will actually think she's the bride.
    via u/LegionBreaker22
  • 07
    I'm honestly upset. I don't want a confrontation, but I feel like it's common knowledge not to wear white to a wedding unless you're the bride. My fiancé agrees with me, and so does my mom, but my brother and Emily are acting like I'm a control freak.
    via u/LegionBreaker22

    Control freak!? This is like Wedding Guests Do's and Don'ts 101. 

  • 08
    I told Emily again (nicely) that she's welcome to come in any other color, but wearing white is a no- go. She rolled her eyes and said she didn't understand why I was being so "uptight" about it. Now I'm wondering if I'm overreacting? So, AITA for sticking to this boundary? 3,763 | 1,602
    via u/LegionBreaker22
  • 09
    Rip Background 6021 • 9h NTA. It's basic wedding etiquette not to wear white unless you're the bride. Emily's refusal to respect that is ride and attention-seeking, no matter how much she "loves how she looks in white." You're not being a control freak; you're asking for a very reasonable boundary on your wedding day. If she can't respect that, that's on her, not you. Reply ✩ 4.5k
    via u/RipBackground6021
  • 10
    LegionBreaker22 OP. 9h Should I just uninvite her? Д 2.5k
    via u/LegionBreaker22

    We are collectively begging you…

  • 11
    Puzzleheaded_Army316.9h Tell her and your brother that if she shows up in white, she will not be allowed in. And make sure that you actually have someone watching the entrance to make sure that she doesn't get in. You don't have to allow her nonsense on YOUR wedding day. She can love the way she looks in white at her own wedding.
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Army316
  • 12
    You are not the AH, but your brother and his fiancee are both ride, disrespectful, and self- absorbed AHS. If you think it wouldn't greatly increase your stress levels and family relationships, you could just uninvite both of them. Because you know that your brother won't be there if you uninvite just her, so uninvite them both. And have someone working the door in case they try to crash. 1 1.8k
    via u/Puzzleheaded_Army316
  • 13
    lermanzo .7h Right? It's not as though she exclusively wears white all the time. 242
    via u/lermanzo

    If she's an anime character that wears the same color scheme every day, then it's okay. But she's not.

  • 14
    dbag_darrell ⚫ 4h if she exclusively wore white all the time she might have some kind of excuse. in this case she is DELIBERATELY choosing to wear white on YOUR wedding. Your brother and her will have an exciting divorce in the future. 180
    via u/dbag_darrell
  • 15
    BILESTOAD • 9h Emily has no idea what kind of looks, comments, reactions she is going to get from every other woman at the event. This is a clear point of etiquette. Not a gray area. Not one other person at the wedding is going to find this acceptable.
    via u/BILESTOAD
  • 16
    She will be regarded as the self-centered, attention-stealing narcissist that she is and will likely have a tantrum when she is treated as such. I don't see her engagement to your brother surviving it. If it does, their marriage surely won't last long anyway, because Emily is a 8 50 ↓
    via u/BILESTOAD
  • 17
    mamabear131 • 9h Write "Not the Bride" on a neon traffic vest. Bring it to the bridal shower and have guests write on it. Make it a HUGE joke that whoever shows up in white has to wear it. Hang it near the door at the Reception. If she shows up in white there is no way in h I she'll put it on. But she'll see it. More importantly EVERYONE will see it. And will know she wore white even though EVERYONE was warned in advance with the vest at the bridal shower. And know she should be wearing it. Allo
    via u/mamabear131

    This is genius.

  • 18
    bllonde_brownie • 8h That's so brilliant. Did you just come up with this or have you seen this done before? Bc that's next level genius and definitely my pick on what OP should do lol 683
    via u/bllonde_brownie
  • 19
    mamabear131 • 7h I saw someone else do it, and I made one for my niece's wedding. Thankfully it was purely for entertainment and no one was the AH - but auntie was on it! I've also learned over the years that people who start drama/love drama aren't such big fans when they're not directing. Let them do what they do and call them out creatively. It takes skill and practice but it's so worth it. 724
    via u/mamabear131
  • 20
    RoseDue 4h Such a clever idea! It's all about turning the tables and making her the center of attention for the wrong reasons. Would definitely make a statement! ... 77 ↓
    via u/RoseDue
  • 21
    AlternativeLie9486 9h The fact that she thought to mention the dress and show it to you tells me she is starting drama. Why else should anyone care what she wears to the wedding? Make it clear to her and your brother that if she shows us wearing white or similar, she will be asked to leave. That's your desire as the bride to be the only person wearing white. If people give you a hard time, you just say, that's the tradition and I'm sticking with it and keep repeating until everyone shuts up. Tel
    via u/AlternativeLie9486
  • 22
    Waddling Kereru • 9h Thats true. If she was truly ignorant then she wouldn't have told you. Has anyone else told you what they plan to wear? 37 ↓
    via u/WaddlingKereru

    She's reveling in the controversy and drama.

  • 23
    rongdog ⚫ 9h • I think you're totally in the right here. It's your wedding day, and you should feel comfortable with how everything goes down, including what guests wear. Wearing white is traditionally reserved for the bride, and it sounds like you've communicated your feelings pretty clearly. Reply 476
    via u/rongdog
  • 24
    LegionBreaker22 OP. 9h But what if she still ends up wearing white ← 179
    via u/LegionBreaker22
  • 25
    Petalwillow 6h NTA at all. Its ur wedding and u get to set the dress code. Its super disrespectful of her to even suggest wearing a white gown. Like is she trying to steal ur thunder or sum? Its not abt insecurity its abt basic courtesy. ... Reply 60 ↓
    via u/Petalwillow

Tags

family drama bride groom wedding drama siblings reddit story relationships wedding couples love wedding dress entitled reddit thread red flag Reddit dating
Scroll Down For The Next Article